Aonach Eagach Learning

19.11.26

On the 5th  August 2023, David Fowler, Graham Cox and Hazel Crombie suffered a fatal fall whilst roped together and traversing the Aonach Eagach Ridge in Glencoe. David Fowler was leading the expedition (David was a qualified Mountaineering and Climbing Instructor and a member of the Association of Mountaineering Instructors). Graham Cox and Hazel Crombie were his clients.


The subsequent Fatal Accident Inquiry held in Fort William established the facts (so far as was possible) relating to the tragedy but could not reach a conclusion as to why the party fell from the ridge.


The Sheriff stopped short of making recommendations for the prevention of further deaths (because, in effect, there was no one to make them to) but he did “hope the mountain guiding community” will reflect on the following areas of concern:

 

  1. Inadequate information provided to clients, both by way of general advertising and specific pre-excursion briefings, regarding the short roping system and its potential use on the Aonach Eagach ridge.
  2. Inadequate detailed proactive discussions with the clients before the excursion, regarding their relative weight, level of experience and competence, equipment and general expectations of the traverse of the Aonach Eagach ridge.
  3. Inadequate prior assessment of the clients’ competence, by way of direct observation rather than merely discussion, before the planned excursion. This point is particularly relevant on an undertaking such as the Aonach Eagach ridge where there is little, if any, opportunity to assess clients’ competence before one of the most difficult sections of the route requires it to be tackled.

 

Considering the above, Mountain Training considers that there are some important and very widely applicable principles in the Sheriff’s report. We would suggest that every leader and instructor should give careful consideration as to:

 

  1. The information that is provided to participants in advance of ventures. The Sheriff expressed the view that it would be helpful to detail the techniques that might be used during the venture. Leaders and instructors might also like to think about how they might record that such pre-event briefings took place.
  2. The information that leaders and instructors collect about their participants in advance of meeting up. This might include previous relevant experience, height, weight and fitness, equipment (or the lack there of), clothing etc. It might also be important to confirm that there is common expectation and understanding as to how the venture will be conducted. Again, it would be best if there was a record (or note) of these discussions.
  3. When meeting participants for the first time, leaders and instructors might consider how they can adequately assess (in a practical way) that the information collected in 1 & 2 above is accurate and commensurate with the skills and abilities required to undertake the planned venture. Itineraries that do not give rise to natural opportunities for practically confirming confidence, such as technical ridge traverses, need special consideration.

 

This note is based on a statement produced by the British Association of Mountain Guides (BMG) and issued to its members. It is endorsed by the Council of Mountain Training UK & Ireland, which comprises the Mountain Training network, the mountaineering councils ( Mountaineering Scotland, Mountaineering Ireland and the BMC), the membership associations (Association of Mountaineering Instructors, British Association of International Mountain Leaders, Mountain Training Association and BMG) and the national outdoor centres (Glenmore Lodge and Plas y Brenin).

 

John Cousins (with grateful thanks to James Thacker, Mark Walker and Iain Peter who wrote the original BMG statement from which this statement has been created.)

5/11/26